A three-judge appeals panel unanimously denied Warner Bros. Television's motion to dismiss Sherri Crichton's lawsuit against HBO Max's medical drama "The Pitt" in November 2026, ruling that the show shares enough similarities with her late husband Michael Crichton's iconic series "ER."
Sherri filed her lawsuit in August 2024, alleging that creators John Wells and Noah Wyle pursued an ER reboot without her approval before rebranding the project as "The Pitt." She described the show as an ER revival "just under a different name," calling the maneuver "a shameful betrayal of [Michael] Crichton and his legacy."
At the heart of the case is a "frozen rights" provision in Michael's contract with Warner Bros. Television, which barred the studio from producing ER spinoffs or reboots without his approval. After Michael died in 2008, Sherri attempted to enforce the provision on behalf of his estate.
Warner Bros. Television initially tried to toss Sherri's lawsuit in November 2026, citing California's anti-SLAPP statute that shields defendants from suits targeting protected speech. However, Judge Wendy Chang denied that motion, finding Sherri presented enough evidence to proceed.
Warner Bros. then appealed – and lost again. The three-judge panel unanimously rejected the studio's bid later that month, stating, "There are clear and numerous similarities between The Pitt and ER; where those similarities lie, on a ladder of abstraction protecting only the more specific expressions, is a matter of 'degree.' Making favorable inferences in Roadrunner's favor, as we must, we find the details here suffice for a prima facie case."
However, the panel dismissed individual claims against creative team members, including Wells and Wyle, finding they were not aware they could be violating Michael's contractual rights.
"I am deeply gratified by the Court of Appeal decision," Sherri said in a statement to Deadline. "[I] look forward to discovery and to our case, which affects writers, creators and their families and estates, being presented to a jury."
Noah Wyle has repeatedly insisted the two shows are fundamentally different projects. In an April 2025 interview with Variety, he stated that once the team paused on developing an ER reboot, the creative group behind The Pitt "pivoted as far in the opposite direction as we could in order to tell the story we wanted to tell."
Wyle further elaborated on the shift in a January 2025 TVLine interview, saying, "The more we went down that road, the more the point got obscured in the reunion aspect, the retread aspect and the reboot aspect. So I was not sorry when we were sort of forced to pivot and figure out how to tell the story in a new way."
The Case Against 'The Pitt'
While Wyle and other creative team members claim The Pitt differs significantly from ER, Sherri's complaint describes the show as "an ER revival just under a different name." According to court documents, she alleged that the creative team pursued an ER reboot before ultimately deciding to rebrand it as The Pitt.
Sherri also cited the frozen rights provision in her husband's contract, arguing that Warner Bros. should have obtained her approval before proceeding with the project. This issue is central to the case, as the provision explicitly bars the studio from producing ER spinoffs or reboots without Crichton's consent.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the nature of Sherri Crichton's lawsuit?
A: Sherri Crichton filed a lawsuit against HBO Max's medical drama "The Pitt" alleging copyright infringement and breach of contract related to the creation and production of the show.
Q: Why did Sherri file her lawsuit in August 2024?
A: Sherri filed her lawsuit after discovering that Warner Bros. Television was pursuing an ER reboot without her approval, allegedly in violation of her late husband Michael Crichton's contract.
Q: How did the appeals court ruling affect the case?
A: The three-judge appeals panel unanimously denied Warner Bros. Television's motion to dismiss Sherri's lawsuit, allowing the case to proceed to trial.