A three-judge panel has unanimously denied an appeal from Warner Bros. Television, allowing Michael Crichton's widow to move forward with her lawsuit against the production company.
According to NBC News, the appeals court ruled that "there are clear and numerous similarities between The Pitt and ER; where those similarities lie, on a ladder of abstraction protecting only the more specific expressions, is a matter of 'degree.'" This decision means that the case will now proceed at the trial court level.
Sherri Crichton filed the lawsuit in August 2024, alleging that the creators of The Pitt, Noah Wyle, John Wells, and R. Scott Gemmill, had initially hoped to reboot ER without receiving her permission. She claimed that they went ahead with producing The Pitt anyway, which she believes violates her contractual rights as the widow of Michael Crichton.
Warner Bros. Television had argued that The Pitt and ER were unrelated, but the court dismissed this claim. In its ruling, the court stated that making favorable inferences in Roadrunner's favor, "we find the details here suffice for a prima facie case."
Crichton's contract with Warner Bros. included a "frozen rights" provision, which prevented the studio from making any spinoffs or reboots without his approval. Despite this, The Pitt premiered on Max last year, featuring a realistic examination of the challenges facing healthcare workers in today's America.
Noah Wyle explained the vision behind The Pitt in an interview with TVLine in January 2025. He said that the team wanted to tell the story in a visually more arresting way than they did back in the '90s, using the new platform of streaming to their advantage.
What Does This Mean for The Pitt Creators?
The denial of Warner Bros.' appeal means that the lawsuit will continue to unfold. Sherri Crichton expressed her gratitude for the Court of Appeal decision, stating that she looks forward to discovery and presenting her case to a jury.
Will The Pitt Be Affected by the Lawsuit?
It remains unclear how the ongoing lawsuit may impact The Pitt's production or future episodes. However, it is likely that the show's creators will need to address the allegations made by Sherri Crichton.
Can The Pitt's Producers Use Material from ER?
As part of her lawsuit, Sherri Crichton claims that the producers of The Pitt used material from ER without her permission. If the court rules in her favor, this could have significant implications for the use of copyrighted material in future productions.
How Long Will the Lawsuit Take to Resolve?
The exact timeline for resolving the lawsuit is uncertain. It may take several months or even years before the case reaches a verdict.