Heather Gay's surprise admission that she's no longer sure whether Jen Shah gave her a black eye during a cast trip has sparked a heated reaction among fans of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City.

During a panel discussion at Bravo Fan Fest on Saturday, Heather revealed that she's changed her mind about who was responsible for the injury, which occurred several seasons ago. When asked by Andy Cohen about the incident, Heather initially seemed confident that Jen was the culprit, but later backtracked, stating that they'll need to "figure it out" together.

"I thought that you had said that Mrs. Shah was responsible," Andy responded, prompting Heather to clarify her statement. "I'm glad she got booed. So over her producing storylines and not being honest. Her and Whitney can go. Bring @monicanikigarcia back!" wrote one commenter on Reality Blurb's Instagram post about the incident.

This development comes after Heather previously claimed that she had "covered" for Jen for three years and was scared of her. She recalled that during the trip, Jen had come into her room the next morning and asked if she had given Heather a black eye and Heather stated she had told her she'd cover for her. However, despite Jen's denial through her representatives and her recent tweet hinting at clearing up the matter, the situation remains unresolved.

Jen Shah is currently in prison, serving time for a separate offense, which adds complexity to the situation. While some fans are calling for Heather to be put on "permanent pause," others argue that this storyline has been dragged out long enough.

The Evolution of Heather and Jen's Friendship

Heather's initial claim that Jen was responsible for the black eye sparked a lot of drama on RHOSLC, particularly since it occurred on a cast trip to Bermuda. However, her change of heart has left many wondering what really happened that night. In an effort to clear up any confusion, Jen tweeted last week that she might finally be ready to talk about the black eye incident.

For now, it seems that both women are choosing to focus on other aspects of their lives. Heather has continued to participate in various Bravo events and projects, while Jen has maintained a relatively low public profile due to her ongoing legal issues.

Frequently Asked Questions

### 1. What exactly did Heather say about Jen giving her a black eye? Heather initially stated that Jen was responsible for the injury, but later clarified that she's no longer sure.

### 2. How have fans reacted to this revelation? Fans are divided, with some expressing frustration and disappointment that Heather would change her story, while others seem to be supportive of her newfound uncertainty.

### 3. Has Jen commented on the situation? Not directly, although she has hinted at wanting to address the issue in a recent tweet.

### 4. Will we see more discussion about this incident on RHOSLC? It's likely that the show will continue to explore this storyline, especially since it involves several key cast members and raises questions about trust and loyalty within the group.

The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City airs Wednesday nights on Bravo, and viewers can expect even more drama and tension as the season unfolds.