Fifteen years after her disappearance, new details have emerged in the investigation into Michelle Parker's murder. A recently filed affidavit sheds light on the events surrounding her death, including allegations of abuse and inconsistencies in Dale Smith II's alibi.

Michelle Parker, 33, went missing on November 17, 2011, after dropping off their twins at Smith's home. While her body has never been recovered, police used enhanced analysis of cellphone location data to justify Smith's arrest. According to the affidavit, Smith claimed Parker was only at his home for about 10 minutes, but the newly analyzed data revealed she was there for over an hour.

The affidavit also highlighted the couple's troubled relationship, citing witness testimony that Smith was abusive towards Parker. Witnesses reported seeing marks on Parker consistent with physical abuse, and one friend claimed Smith made threatening comments towards Parker during an argument. Prior to her disappearance, Parker expressed concerns to friends about how she and Smith were portrayed on The People's Court, stating she felt embarrassed by Judge Marilyn Milian's behavior towards them.

During their appearance on the show, Judge Milian ordered Parker to pay $2,500 following a dispute over an engagement ring. In a statement included in the affidavit, investigators wrote that Parker "found it embarrassing" due to the judge's actions. The affidavit also includes texts between Parker and Smith, which showed they had exchanged insults in the weeks leading up to her disappearance.

One text exchange in particular caught investigators' attention. Two weeks before her death, Parker allegedly sent a message saying, "Mourn for ur kids too! U lost em," adding "They'll b goin with me ahole." This threat came amidst Parker's growing concerns about losing custody of their children to Smith.

While the affidavit paints a picture of a tumultuous relationship marked by abuse and mistrust, investigators have yet to determine if they believe Smith had a motive for killing Parker. Orlando police Detective Phil McMican told reporters that authorities examined Smith's inconsistent statements during depositions in a civil case. McMican stated that Smith gave different answers to similar questions asked numerous times over the years.

Smith, 55, was arrested on October 14 and is currently being held without bond in Orange County Jail. He has pleaded not guilty to the second-degree murder charge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What new evidence led to Dale Smith II's arrest?

The new affidavit reveals that police used enhanced analysis of cellphone location data to justify Smith's arrest. This analysis contradicts Smith's initial claim that Parker was only at his home for 10 minutes.

What does the affidavit reveal about the couple's relationship?

The affidavit cites witness testimony that Smith was physically abusive towards Parker. Witnesses reported seeing marks on Parker consistent with abuse, and one friend claimed Smith made threatening comments towards Parker during an argument.

Can investigators confirm a motive for Michelle Parker's murder?

While the affidavit highlights inconsistencies in Smith's alibi and allegations of abuse, investigators have yet to confirm whether they believe Smith had a motive for killing Parker.

Where is Dale Smith II being held while awaiting trial?

Smith is currently being held without bond in Orange County Jail.